Joined: 19/08/2006(UTC) Posts: 31 Location: Toronto,
|
Hello again A piece of advice in regards to which boosters are available and what would be a cheaper way to go. I have a layout spread on a 120/240 cm plywood board controlled by a CS. Every time I run trains I get another idea of how I could rearrange the layout. I have about 14 turnouts out of which 8 are controlled through Viessmann decoders which I like due to the separate power supply I can use without affecting the train and lights dimming. The other 6 are 74460 which I prefer to use in spots where I "have a feeling" that the layout may change, but every time I use those I get problems with the lights on the locomotives and some cars that have interior lighting. I read about the "no-no" of running parallel transformers. Is this due only due to the danger of getting zapped if you unplug one with the other one plugged in, or there is no efficiency due to the fact that the signal is not digitized? CAN IT HARM THE CS? I just want to get the flicker out of the way (at least for now) 'till my layout will begin to grow, so that's why I do not want to go spending too much. I will be getting another 6021 soon. Is that suitable in any way? Any advice is appreciated and I am already looking forward for replies Andy
|
|
|
|
Joined: 15/01/2003(UTC) Posts: 707 Location: Texas, USA
|
Hello Andy,
The transformer powers the CS, and the CS "adds" a digital signal to it. Adding a second transformer without a booster would mean that it has no digital signal, and thus is useless. If you do not seperate the track (have two seperate circuits for each transformer), you would end up powering the CS the wrong way (through its output), which may very well damage the CS (I am not going to test it).
Wait for the new boosters, and buy one of them when they are here.
Charlie |
|
|
|
|
Joined: 29/08/2003(UTC) Posts: 1,915 Location: Netherlands
|
You can buy a motorola (mm) booster. But if you do. Buy a regulated booster. The old Marklin mm booster from were unregulated. |
M-track with a CS2. |
|
|
|
Joined: 01/02/2004(UTC) Posts: 7,452 Location: Scotland
|
We can only hope these boosters turn up soon !!
Andy why a 6021 and not a MS to attach to your CS.
David |
Take care I like Marklin and will defend the worlds greatest model rail manufacturer. |
|
|
|
Joined: 04/06/2002(UTC) Posts: 754 Location: Täby
|
Quote:[size=1" face="Verdana" id="quote]quote:Originally posted by Andy18
I read about the "no-no" of running parallel transformers. Is this due only due to the danger of getting zapped if you unplug one with the other one plugged in, or there is no efficiency due to the fact that the signal is not digitized? CAN IT HARM THE CS?
<hr noshade size="1] If you mean connecting two transformers to the same CS or booster: Don't do it!!! It is useless, since the CS can't use more power than you get from a single trafo anyway. And it's dangerous, since the two power sources may have opposite phase - creating an enormous shortcut. As an extra bonus you may also get electrocuted when you remove one of the plugs from the wall outlet while the other is still connected. The only way to use an extra transformer in your layout is to connect it through a booster - that feeds a separate circuit. The cheapest solution is to feed the accessories through a Delta Control. In theory it can also feed the tracks, but there is a delay in its' signal, so it should be avoided. A separate power source for the accessories is always a good idea, since the power drops don't affect the trains... |
K-G / H0 and Z model train user |
|
|
|
Joined: 19/08/2006(UTC) Posts: 31 Location: Toronto,
|
So the way to go is with a booster. What do you recommend? Any links you can submit? Davy, do you have a link for the motorola booster? Thank you all Andy
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/10/2001(UTC) Posts: 2,379 Location: Lindome, Sweden
|
Just to clear things out - what do you mean with a CS (as you say "Another 6021"). CS(Cemtral Station) is the name of the new central unit with large touch screen. 6021 is the old one, sometimes also called Central Unit.
Normally you don't use two central stations in one system; only one can be central.
If you have a 6021, you may use a 6017 booster, and also older ones like 6015. You may also use third party boosters as Uhlenbrocks Power 3. I don't know of any regulated boosters.
You'll pay a hight price for the convenience of using 74460 decoders. I personally am not prepared to do that; saving power by using Viessmann decoders is my choice.
/Lars
|
|
|
|
Joined: 03/01/2003(UTC) Posts: 5,181 Location: Southern New Jersey, USA
|
Andy: AFAIK, there are currently no boosters on the market which will pass mfx signals. The Marklin 60172 is not yet in production and no one else can make them. If you want to have mfx throughout your layout and can wait, I would recommend that you wait for the 60172. If you need something now, I use LDT DB2's on my (non-mfx) layout. See http://www.ldt-infocente...nglish/home_frame_e.htm. George Kuhn in Marietta PA (http://www.eurobahntrains.com/) carries them. I don't know if other stores do or not. |
|
|
|
|
Joined: 06/03/2005(UTC) Posts: 1,159 Location: The Netherlands
|
Quote:[size=1" face="Verdana" id="quote]quote:Originally posted by Charlie <br />Hello Andy,
The transformer powers the CS, and the CS "adds" a digital signal to it. Adding a second transformer without a booster would mean that it has no digital signal, and thus is useless. If you do not seperate the track (have two seperate circuits for each transformer), you would end up powering the CS the wrong way (through its output), which may very well damage the CS (I am not going to test it).
Wait for the new boosters, and buy one of them when they are here.
Charlie
According to me this is also not possible.  Picture is from the manual from the Mobile Station. |
Absolutly AFB-NOHAB fan ;-) |
|
|
|
Joined: 19/10/2005(UTC) Posts: 393 Location: Aarhus C, DK
|
Quote:[size=1" face="Verdana" id="quote]quote: Originally posted by MärCoAccording to me this is also not possible.  Picture is from the manual from the Mobile Station. This is possible, i am using this on my layout. The same with my lamps, I put the ground wire to the closest track, and the other wire to my second trafo. Michael |
Märklin C-tracks, Mobile Station, Danish Ep 4 |
|
|
|
Joined: 19/08/2006(UTC) Posts: 31 Location: Toronto,
|
Hi guys Thanks for all the replys To clear some things out: 1. I have a Central Station 2. I also have a Mobile Station 3. I am awaiting for a starter set that has a 6021. I was wondering if the 6021 could be used in any way as a booster if powered by a separate transformer. I do not have any problems powering accessories since I don't have any at the time. I have some tunouts controlled through Viessmann decoders with a sepparate power supply which I like a lot because they do not put any strain on the track's power supply and also they react extremly fast and "solid", while the 74460 are weak and slow to respond, and to top everything up when activated, they dim the light in the coaches, which is my main complaint. I am using the 74460 due to the ease of being able to move turnouts arround when I feel like it and I don't have to move wiring arround which also looks ugly on top of the layout. Question: If the MS can only handle approx 20VA, the CS can handle approx 40VA, why do some sets come with a 60VA transformer. I was thinking that the digitized voltage is mainly important for the "duty cycle" of the loks and some of the functions such as lights are on a "on or off" principle, therefore the more power to the tracks, less problems with the load applied to tracks showing on the lights in the coaches for example. I have a Santa Fe which while idling on tracks with the lights on, when I activate one tunout controlled by a 74460, the light go dim (almost off) for the duration of the switch (250ms) as controlled by the CS. So, if I get a 60VA transformer to go with my CS, will that help cure my dimming lights problem, or I will still be limited by the CS's 40VA limitation? Sorry for the long post, but I want to be as clear as possible Andy
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/10/2001(UTC) Posts: 2,379 Location: Lindome, Sweden
|
- No, 6021 can't be used as booster (except, together with the Intellibox). - The CS (and every other digital station) limits it's output power. I would guess that CS needs 60 VA in order to be able to deliver it's maximum output, about 50 VA; the principle is correct but the measures probably not. But I would be surprised if the CS limits to 40 VA. - So, answer is that 60 VA might be a little waste, but just a little. The CS itself needs some power too. - I'm not clear what transformer you use today, but I would think that going from 40 VA to 60 would help, but going further - not. - As said, there is currently no booster which can be used without problems with the CS. Maybe next summer. All current boosters need a ski lifter between CS-segment and booster segments. - I won't repeat what I think about the overall design of Märklin/systems.
/Lars
|
|
|
|
Joined: 12/07/2003(UTC) Posts: 297 Location: Brisbane, QLD
|
Quote:[size=1" face="Verdana" id="quote]quote:Originally posted by Lars Westerlind <br />- No, 6021 can't be used as booster (except, together with the Intellibox). - The CS (and every other digital station) limits it's output power. I would guess that CS needs 60 VA in order to be able to deliver it's maximum output, about 50 VA; the principle is correct but the measures probably not. But I would be surprised if the CS limits to 40 VA. - So, answer is that 60 VA might be a little waste, but just a little. The CS itself needs some power too. - I'm not clear what transformer you use today, but I would think that going from 40 VA to 60 would help, but going further - not. - As said, there is currently no booster which can be used without problems with the CS. Maybe next summer. All current boosters need a ski lifter between CS-segment and booster segments. - I won't repeat what I think about the overall design of Märklin/systems.
/Lars
Lars, can yoou not use a 6017 together with a 60129? It says and I quote - "connection device for using the 6015 or 6017 boosters with Marklin Systems" |
Noel |
|
|
|
Joined: 04/06/2002(UTC) Posts: 754 Location: Täby
|
Quote:[size=1" face="Verdana" id="quote]quote: Originally posted by Noel Loganathan<br /> Quote:[size=1" face="Verdana" id="quote]quote:Originally posted by Lars Westerlind <br />- No, 6021 can't be used as booster (except, together with the Intellibox). - The CS (and every other digital station) limits it's output power. I would guess that CS needs 60 VA in order to be able to deliver it's maximum output, about 50 VA; the principle is correct but the measures probably not. But I would be surprised if the CS limits to 40 VA. - So, answer is that 60 VA might be a little waste, but just a little. The CS itself needs some power too. - I'm not clear what transformer you use today, but I would think that going from 40 VA to 60 would help, but going further - not. - As said, there is currently no booster which can be used without problems with the CS. Maybe next summer. All current boosters need a ski lifter between CS-segment and booster segments. - I won't repeat what I think about the overall design of Märklin/systems.
/Lars
Lars, can yoou not use a 6017 together with a 60129? It says and I quote - "connection device for using the 6015 or 6017 boosters with Marklin Systems" That is the solution offered right now from Märklin. It is only useful if you already have one or more 6015 or 6017 boosters that you want to use with the CS. To buy these boosters as well as the connection device is unnecessarily expensive, since the price of the new mfx enabled booster will be about the same as for the old model. With this booster setup you have to use rocker insulators between booster segments. The mfx feedback won't work on segments connected to a booster. You can still drive the locos on all parts of the layout, but if you put a new mfx loco on the track it will have to start on the segment powered straight from the CS. |
K-G / H0 and Z model train user |
|
|
|
Joined: 17/09/2006(UTC) Posts: 18,771 Location: New Zealand
|
Quote:[size=1" face="Verdana" id="quote]quote:Originally posted by kgsjoqvist
That is the solution offered right now from Märklin. It is only useful if you already have one or more 6015 or 6017 boosters that you want to use with the CS. To buy these boosters as well as the connection device is unnecessarily expensive, since the price of the new mfx enabled booster will be about the same as for the old model.
With this booster setup you have to use rocker insulators between booster segments. The mfx feedback won't work on segments connected to a booster. You can still drive the locos on all parts of the layout, but if you put a new mfx loco on the track it will have to start on the segment powered straight from the CS.
This is my understanding of things. You could probably also use a delta controller as a poor man's booster, along with the appropriate rocker insulators, etc. As for connecting a 6021 to a CS and using the 6021 as a booster, well this is theoretically possible. The diagram of the Marklin Systems architecture (see pg 406 of the 2006 catalog) shows a 60128 connection device which is meant to be able to connect a 6021 to a CS via the 60128 and a 60125 terminal. However, I don't think the 60128 is available yet.........
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/10/2001(UTC) Posts: 2,379 Location: Lindome, Sweden
|
Noel, you got the answer before I read your question. 6015, 6017 and Delta Control, as well as some compatible boosters may be used, but none of them can be used without ski lifter / rocker inusulator. And I've tried those lifters some time agi, and will never use them again.
Another option is to buy two 6017 and let your CS drive your k83's and programming track only. Would work, but seems insane to me as well.
Funny, whenever I think of Märklin/systems system design, it takes a lot of effort not to speak what I think about it.
/Lars
|
|
|
|
Joined: 17/09/2006(UTC) Posts: 18,771 Location: New Zealand
|
The other alternative to using the rocker insulators would be to use a piece of dead track, slightly longer than the largest loco ski, insulated at both ends, placed in between the 2 booster segments. The obvious problem with this is that trains would need enough momentum to pass through the dead section, and would jerk a bit, which could cause derailment. You'd probably want to do this inside a tunnel. It's not ideal but gets away from using rocker insulators.
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/08/2006(UTC) Posts: 31 Location: Toronto,
|
Originally posted by Lars Westerlind
- The CS (and every other digital station) limits it's output power. I would guess that CS needs 60 VA in order to be able to deliver it's maximum output, about 50 VA; the principle is correct but the measures probably not. But I would be surprised if the CS limits to 40 VA. - So, answer is that 60 VA might be a little waste, but just a little. The CS itself needs some power too.
I think the first step is to get a 60VA transformer since they are now available for 120V (I am using the 42VA version), so off I go to the store. I will post results after I'll try it. Thank you again for all the support Andy
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/08/2006(UTC) Posts: 31 Location: Toronto,
|
Got the transformer. While purchasing it I told my dealer the story with the dimming lights when using the 74460, and he told me that untill the 60VA trafo arrived to Canada he also used the 42VA with the CS and the CS behaved poorly. After switching to the 60 VA he said everything was OK. Unfortunatelly he did not elaborate on his problems. Back to my story, I could say that the lights do not dim as much, but they still do. There is little power demand on the transformer when this happens: The Santa Fe has its lights on but no sound and is not even moving, the 43604 Express Train Passenger Car with its lights on. That's it. And when I activate ANY of the 74460 on the track this happens. As long as there will be no other problems created by this power surge I guess I could live with it, but I don't know if everytime this happens I am creating a potential other problem. Andy
|
|
|
|
Joined: 30/01/2006(UTC) Posts: 1,893 Location: Keene, NH
|
Andy: Since the portion of the digital signal that is used for accessories is unchanged since the original 6020 days, you can definitely use a Delta controller and power pack as a booster for your turnouts. You just need to make sure that the power to them is kept separate. These can be picked up used for as little as $10. Combined with a 32VA starter transformer and some simple wiring and...instant, cheap booster! Peter has a great drawing of how this works on his web site: http://peter.funck.net/power.htmr/mark  |
|
|
|
|
Joined: 30/01/2006(UTC) Posts: 1,893 Location: Keene, NH
|
Andy: I put together a quick drawing myself. This is shown with a 6021, but will also work with a CS! r/mark   |
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/08/2006(UTC) Posts: 31 Location: Toronto,
|
The 74460 decoder receives both power and signal through a pair of wires which after being processed through the decoder will activate the 74490 motor through the 3 wires. The 2 wires should go directly to the track to receive the signal/power required to operate the motor. If I power the decoder separately I lose the signal. What I am trying to do is to be free of any wiring linking the turnouts to the layout, that's why I use the 74460. Otherwise I am very happy using the Viessmann decoders that can be fed separate power supply, in which case when I activate the turnout the only power used from the CS is just the digital signal and there is absolutely no power drop. Andy
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/10/2001(UTC) Posts: 2,379 Location: Lindome, Sweden
|
Andy has got it, mark not. As Andy uses Viessmann-dekoders for the stationary part, where the 6604 could be used, he already saved most of the power. The Viessmann-dekoders draw very little digital power.
I certainly support Andy to wait segmenting the track unneededly; get a 60 VA first, try using function decoders if cars are lighted (so it could be turned off), and try retrofit Delta-locos with kits using permanent magnet. In that case 60 VA will last very long. I have no booster currently, and do have several locos, decoders, and square meters of layout.
/Lars
|
|
|
|
Joined: 30/01/2006(UTC) Posts: 1,893 Location: Keene, NH
|
Lars:
He already has the 60VA transformer and still has the problem. I use K83's or LDT decoders for all of my turnouts which allows me to do what I showed in the diagram. Just trying to help!
r/mark |
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/10/2001(UTC) Posts: 2,379 Location: Lindome, Sweden
|
OK, I was one message behind, sorry. /Lars
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/08/2006(UTC) Posts: 31 Location: Toronto,
|
Talking to a friend of mine over the weekend who visited and saw the problem, he is telling me that the problem could be corrected by installing a larger capacitor after the rectifing bridge, but he would like a schematics not to screw things up. The existing one is 10mf, and he thinks that a higher capacity one will dampen the momentary power draw. If anybody has the schematics to the 74460 and could submit the diagram, I would very much appreciated it. There is an emulation of the 74460 on Bogobit page, but is not the same one. As well,unfortunatlly , some of the links on that site are dead as well Andy
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/10/2001(UTC) Posts: 2,379 Location: Lindome, Sweden
|
Sorry Andy, the idea is right, if there is space. Sorry I don't have any schema. But I wonder, do you mean 10 mF? I don't think so, that should be far mot than enough and not fit on the board. 10 uF (micro Farad)? That seems too little to me.
Regards, Lars
|
|
|
|
Joined: 19/08/2006(UTC) Posts: 31 Location: Toronto,
|
10 microfard it is. (no micro on my keyboard!) He said maybe a tantal one might work. they are fairly small Andy
|
|
|
|
Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.