Joined: 12/05/2023(UTC) Posts: 6 Location: San Jose, San Jose
|
I would like to make several 188 cms blocks for train detection & automation. Should I: 1. Convert one (1) 24188 to contact track and use two 74030 (red insulators) in each end of the block? 2. Two contact tracks (converted 24188s), one at each end also with 74030 red insulations in each end of the block. 3. Should I have to convert all the 10 24188 track pieces to contact 24188s and also use the red insulators at each end of the block?. Each block will have one connection to an S88. Thanks for the advice. Lionel Peralta.
|
|
|
|
Joined: 13/02/2017(UTC) Posts: 159 Location: Ottawa, ON
|
Hello "lperalta",
If you expect more people to see your post and reply, then please move it to the "general" topic and not in this "Events, forum member meers, exhibiotn & TV shows" topic.
/* Moved */ |
Andry
// Marklin HO K track; ECoS; TrainController Gold; Marklin & ESU decoders; Arduino controlled Switches, Semaphores & Accessories (DCC); Win 11 //
|
 2 users liked this useful post by Kiko
|
|
|
Joined: 11/06/2007(UTC) Posts: 208 Location: Eslöv, Sweden
|
Hi,
For each block I use 3 detection places. Let say that the block consists of 10 pieces 24188. I then isolate 1 piece at each end and the 8 pieces between as one detection. I use Traincontroller for automation and set the 2 end pieces as stop markers and all 3 as occupancy. This means that the entire block is detected as occupancy. In this way the system can also detect lost cars and the end pieces make for exact stop points.
Hope it makes sense, Peder
|
 2 users liked this useful post by pederbc
|
|
|
Joined: 04/02/2011(UTC) Posts: 3,562 Location: Paris, France
|
Hi Lionel The conventional way to make detection zones using C Track is exactly as you say: - just cutting 2 contact bridges under each rail of the section and isolate each extremity with one red isolator sleeve 74030. - the insulated section is connected to an M88 (60881 or 60883) for forwarding the occupation to the CS3, CS2, etc - this is the best way and it is reversible (you may re-connect the bridges to use rails as normal one Where to install the detection zones?- when using a CS3 / CS2 alone then you must have signals / relays commanding stop sections. In this case you may have one section after (downstream) the signal which will command the signal to green or red depending on the occupation. - when using a CS3 /CS2 in combination with Rocrail or equivanet, you don't need any stop / insulated sections, nor any brake module. In this case, most of the time I use 2 detection zones per block (1) to slow down the train from route speed to station / approach speed and (2) to command the smooth stop . The bid difference is Rocrail (or equivalent) knows where is each train and so can issue slow down or stop orders to specific locos Length of contact tracks- it is true that using one rail for occupation detection works well when rails and wheels are clean but sometimes may cause some short locos to stop because of ground return issues. - on the other hand, having a full zone protected by a signal provides an excellent security - so I have detections where it is needed and in a typical block, the last 20 cm ahead of the signal are for smooth stopping and the rest of the block (1 m to 2 m) for the slow-down section - I avoided making contact tracks with C-track turnouts (this is perfectly possible) by reluctance of the extra work and surgery Here is a small video on Rocrail / CS3 operation with occupancy block Cheers Jean |
|
 1 user liked this useful post by JohnjeanB
|
|
|
Joined: 12/05/2023(UTC) Posts: 6 Location: San Jose, San Jose
|
Originally Posted by: JohnjeanB  Hi Lionel The conventional way to make detection zones using C Track is exactly as you say: - just cutting 2 contact bridges under each rail of the section and isolate each extremity with one red isolator sleeve 74030. - the insulated section is connected to an M88 (60881 or 60883) for forwarding the occupation to the CS3, CS2, etc - this is the best way and it is reversible (you may re-connect the bridges to use rails as normal one Where to install the detection zones?- when using a CS3 / CS2 alone then you must have signals / relays commanding stop sections. In this case you may have one section after (downstream) the signal which will command the signal to green or red depending on the occupation. - when using a CS3 /CS2 in combination with Rocrail or equivanet, you don't need any stop / insulated sections, nor any brake module. In this case, most of the time I use 2 detection zones per block (1) to slow down the train from route speed to station / approach speed and (2) to command the smooth stop . The bid difference is Rocrail (or equivalent) knows where is each train and so can issue slow down or stop orders to specific locos Length of contact tracks- it is true that using one rail for occupation detection works well when rails and wheels are clean but sometimes may cause some short locos to stop because of ground return issues. - on the other hand, having a full zone protected by a signal provides an excellent security - so I have detections where it is needed and in a typical block, the last 20 cm ahead of the signal are for smooth stopping and the rest of the block (1 m to 2 m) for the slow-down section - I avoided making contact tracks with C-track turnouts (this is perfectly possible) by reluctance of the extra work and surgery Here is a small video on Rocrail / CS3 operation with occupancy block Cheers Jean Thanks a lot. I have the CS3+. When you mention M88 probably you wanted to say S88, right?. If I use 2 detection tracks per block, both will have to be wired to the S88 even if they belong to the same block? The center pieces in our 10 track block will remain intact, right?. Thanks again. Lionel
|
|
|
|
Joined: 04/02/2011(UTC) Posts: 3,562 Location: Paris, France
|
Originally Posted by: lperalta  When you mention M88 probably you wanted to say S88, right?. If I use 2 detection tracks per block, both will have to be wired to the S88 even if they belong to the same block? The center pieces in our 10 track block will remain intact, right?. Thanks again. Lionel Hi Of course I got confused and I mean to use 60881 and 60883 and not those old 6088 and 60880 with their unreliable flat cable (bad contacts and sensitivity to electrical noise). Even when belonging to the same block, the slow-down andf stop sections needs be independant Will the center pieces remain intact? When using only a CS3+ without any s/w control then you may have the central rails intact. It reduces the security but improves the current pick-up Cheers Jean |
|
|
|
|
Joined: 12/05/2023(UTC) Posts: 6 Location: San Jose, San Jose
|
Originally Posted by: JohnjeanB  Originally Posted by: lperalta  When you mention M88 probably you wanted to say S88, right?. If I use 2 detection tracks per block, both will have to be wired to the S88 even if they belong to the same block? The center pieces in our 10 track block will remain intact, right?. Thanks again. Lionel Hi Of course I got confused and I mean to use 60881 and 60883 and not those old 6088 and 60880 with their unreliable flat cable (bad contacts and sensitivity to electrical noise). Even when belonging to the same block, the slow-down andf stop sections needs be independant Will the center pieces remain intact? When using only a CS3+ without any s/w control then you may have the central rails intact. It reduces the security but improves the current pick-up Cheers Jean Thank you very much!.
|
|
|
|
Joined: 12/05/2023(UTC) Posts: 6 Location: San Jose, San Jose
|
Originally Posted by: pederbc  Hi,
For each block I use 3 detection places. Let say that the block consists of 10 pieces 24188. I then isolate 1 piece at each end and the 8 pieces between as one detection. I use Traincontroller for automation and set the 2 end pieces as stop markers and all 3 as occupancy. This means that the entire block is detected as occupancy. In this way the system can also detect lost cars and the end pieces make for exact stop points.
Hope it makes sense, Peder
Thanks Peder.... I understand your advice. I am using CS3+. My question now is> Let´s suposse I use the outside rail as detection rail. 1. Should I isolate the preceding track of the block on the last one as well?. 2. When you say you use three detection places, do you mean you make 3 contact tracks each one of them connected to the S88???, using 3 ports of the S88???. 3. What do you see in the screen... 3 contact tracks activated or each contact track activates when the wheels enter the contact track???. Thanks. Lionel
|
|
|
|
Joined: 12/05/2023(UTC) Posts: 6 Location: San Jose, San Jose
|
Originally Posted by: JohnjeanB  Originally Posted by: lperalta  When you mention M88 probably you wanted to say S88, right?. If I use 2 detection tracks per block, both will have to be wired to the S88 even if they belong to the same block? The center pieces in our 10 track block will remain intact, right?. Thanks again. Lionel Hi Of course I got confused and I mean to use 60881 and 60883 and not those old 6088 and 60880 with their unreliable flat cable (bad contacts and sensitivity to electrical noise). Even when belonging to the same block, the slow-down andf stop sections needs be independant Will the center pieces remain intact? When using only a CS3+ without any s/w control then you may have the central rails intact. It reduces the security but improves the current pick-up Cheers Jean Merry Christmas Jean. I am not sure where should I place the 74030 isolation pieces in your example?. Just one at the preceding track and one at the end of the block?. Or each contact track within the block (the first one and the last one) should be isolated???. With one or two 74030 at each end of the contact track??? Thanks a lot. Lionel
|
|
|
|
Joined: 04/02/2011(UTC) Posts: 3,562 Location: Paris, France
|
Hi Lionel Here is a section of C Tracks as seen from underneath. - The three center track pieces are isolated (the 2 bridges on each section are cut) - the top rail on the picture is selected to be the isolated one so at each of its extremity, a 74030 inslator is inserted in the contact shoes - the insulated rail section is connected to the S88 (60881) occupancy detector  Cheers Jean |
|
 1 user liked this useful post by JohnjeanB
|
|
|
Joined: 11/06/2007(UTC) Posts: 208 Location: Eslöv, Sweden
|
Yes, it takes a lot of S88 ports. I use the Traincontroller software from Freiwald.com. When setting up all blocks like this it makes for very accurate driving and stopping, but also for safe automation of the trains. If you’re only using the CS3 for automation the maybe it’s an overkill. I have been using the ESU ECoS for ßeveral years now and have just ordered a CS3 to replace it. Should arrive tomorrow :-). Looking forward to see what it can do with automation.
Thanks Jean for the picture of the isolation. If you’re using this kind of detection I recommend using the ”Diode trick” to bring grounding to the detection track. You can search for this on the forum.
Merry holidays, Peder
|
|
|
|
Joined: 28/09/2019(UTC) Posts: 119 Location: Rogaland, Haugesund
|
Hi If you use events in CS3 you can use one short detection track in each end of the blocks and one in the middle (each connected to an s88 contact) you can use these as triggers for speed canges. Slow down at entering a block, slow to creep at mid sensor and stop at end block. If acceleration and decelleration are properly set for the loco this will provide perfect slow down/ stop at a station…. Same trick in next block to provide creep start out from station and further speed increase at next detection(this can also be obtained using to speed commands after each orher in the event(with a suitable time delay between the first and second) no braking module or signals required. For train stop from creep to standstill entering a station i often use the switch direction command. This overide the decelleration delay, train stops from creep with a small jerk… not uncommon I think… also it will stop at exact same spot each time. For occupancy of blocks I use a virtual contact in cs3(no connection to S88 needed) there is one virtual contact for each block. When writing the event the event is set to check for required blocks to be un occupied(then set them to occupied) for the trains own use… then set train speed. When entering the sensor in next block(ex middle one if train is short enough to have cleared previous block) the event set the previous block to un occupied and available for other events(trains) vaiting for free blocks…. Regards Thor
|
|
|
|
Joined: 12/05/2023(UTC) Posts: 6 Location: San Jose, San Jose
|
Originally Posted by: Tie  Hi If you use events in CS3 you can use one short detection track in each end of the blocks and one in the middle (each connected to an s88 contact) you can use these as triggers for speed canges. Slow down at entering a block, slow to creep at mid sensor and stop at end block. If acceleration and decelleration are properly set for the loco this will provide perfect slow down/ stop at a station…. Same trick in next block to provide creep start out from station and further speed increase at next detection(this can also be obtained using to speed commands after each orher in the event(with a suitable time delay between the first and second) no braking module or signals required. For train stop from creep to standstill entering a station i often use the switch direction command. This overide the decelleration delay, train stops from creep with a small jerk… not uncommon I think… also it will stop at exact same spot each time. For occupancy of blocks I use a virtual contact in cs3(no connection to S88 needed) there is one virtual contact for each block. When writing the event the event is set to check for required blocks to be un occupied(then set them to occupied) for the trains own use… then set train speed. When entering the sensor in next block(ex middle one if train is short enough to have cleared previous block) the event set the previous block to un occupied and available for other events(trains) vaiting for free blocks…. Regards Thor Thank you all for teaching me. Happy new year!
|
|
|
|
Joined: 04/02/2021(UTC) Posts: 480 Location: USA
|
Great thread. Fyi, M track users need dedicated feedback track pieces or make their own. The latter is a bit more involved than the simple 'snips' of C track. Ben  |
|
 1 user liked this useful post by BenP
|
|
|
Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.