In my opinion this is the mother of "functional models" for
digital operation. Rutger Friberg published 1988 the idea, including a
self made project with a similar crane. He also proposed the idea for
several manufacturers, and it was ROCO that took it into production. The
reviewed model is the "AC" version 46900, meaning of course that
it's Märklin/Motorola protocol compatible.
It's a model of a railway breakdown down
crane, which may be pulled around by any loco. It has an built in decoder,
three motors, and one extra connection. The motors are for rotating the
boom, lift/lower it, and for raising/lowering the hook. The extra
connection could be used for work light, an electromagnet (or excavator shovel).
The address is set in the same way as usual for Märklin/Motorola format:
dip switch. Address 30 is the factory setting. It understands the
"old" Märklin protocol, meaning that both Märklin 6020 and
6021 is fully useable.
You control it by first selecting one of
four modes, see below, and than by speed and direction knob operating the
selected function. If you press the "off" function shortly, you
cycle the four modes in the indicated order, if you select
"function" for more than 2-3 s, you cycle in the opposite order.
A LED (Light emitting diode) indicates the mode by blinking, and the state
of the accessory by it's color.
Function |
Indication |
Control |
Rotate |
X _ _ _ X _
_ _ |
Speed and
direction set as for a Loco. |
Boom |
X X _ _ X X
_ _ |
Speed and
direction set as for a Loco. |
Hook |
X X X _ X X
X _ |
Speed and
direction set as for a Loco. |
Function |
Steady on |
Direction
change toggles the function on/off. |
The led has green light if the function
is off, and red if it's on. It remains on/off regardless if function is
switched. The other functions are stopped if you change mode of operation
(but not if you change address; beware: it's does not automatically stop
when there is no thread left!).
An important additional note: it's
unfortunately not perfect to switch between going in a train, and
operating the crane. The crane house MUST be released from the motor when
run through the curves, by manually switching a lever on the side of the
lower part, the car. And, if you want to lift heavy loads (25 g), you must
manually attach enclosed supports to the crane.
The accessories are bought separately; the 46806 with work light and
electro magnet. There is also a shovel available as 46807 which may be
opened and closed, more suitable for the harbor crane, but fully
functional also for this one. One of these may be connected into a small
socket in the crane house, beside the boom. The cables of the magnet are a
little bit tricky to keep from disturbing the operation. If you prefer the
lamp, it's attached to the boom, and the cables are no problems here.
Derailing
sensitivity |
4 |
The feeling
is very good, two three axle bogies, heavy, but it's large,
especially in the curves, too large for my narrow layout. |
Speed
characteristics |
5 |
Interpreted
as the motor function: Excellent. The motors are very silent, and
are running in the best speed range. From very slow to
moderate. |
Detailing
and looks |
4 |
The right
level for function model I think; not so many details that may
break, but still nice. |
Model
choice |
5 |
The good
note is not for the looks, it's for the function |
Features |
5 |
No
comments. |
Playability |
2 |
No, no, no.
It's for daddy. |
Fun for
child |
3 |
OK. But
most children can't handle it I think. |
Overall
impression |
5 |
Must buy |
The operation of it seems primitive on the paper, but works quite ok. I
would have used the LED to indicate the direction of each function, not
only the state of the accessory; it's difficult to remember if the hook is
on it's way up or down. But no great problem.
The advantage of not using f1-f4 is
two-fold:
- It works with both old and new
Motorola protocol
- You don't have to move hands; one
finger on the "off" key, and the other hand on the speed
dial, so you can keep your eyes on the crane. And a ROCO lokmaus
connected to the Intellibox is also enough to fully control the
train.
Motor |
3 silent,
miniature motors |
|
"Decoder" |
Like
c80/c81 + extra logic circuits |
|
Axles |
3+3 in two bogies, crane boom support car two
axles. |
|
Lights
front
Lights rear |
- |
|
Coupler
front
Coupler rear |
Coupler
pocket w enclosed ROCO universal coupler AND loop coupler. |
|
|